Astronomy Students' Association
SEPTEMBER 2001
Reviews, summaries, and news from talks, colloquiua, and events occurring in a PMA student's second home, RLM.

The reviews presented here are mere interpretations of talks, seminars, and colloquiua given by various speakers and are therefore subject to errors, misinterpretation, and faulty wiring. They should in no way be used to convey the speaker's true message, whenever possible, a credible literature source will be provided.

Map of CMB fluctuations from COBE Sept. 11, 2001
Birth and Fate of the Universe
Marc Kamionkowski (Caltech)

Cosmology has always been confusing to me. The week of Sept. 10 to 14 featured two talks on the subject who's introductions cleared up some of my confusion. The first was in the Astronomy Department by Dr. Kamionkowski. He came packing the latest data from the BOOMERanG balloon instrument. He wants to show that the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) anisotropy, or one degree (angular size) temperature fluctuations, are due to gravity waves. This would give scientists insight on both the birth and fate of the universe. The BOOMERanG experiment measured the CMB angular power spectrum peaks and the results support models that assume a CMB structure of one degree and a flat universe. On the contrary, some researchers believe that the CMB anisotropy is due to density pertubations. However, the models of the CMB angular power spectrum for density pertubations and gravity waves are identical and indistinguishable. So how can Dr. Kamionkowski make his case? By looking at the polarization of the angular power spectrum. He believes new satellites and instruments will be able to measure this polarization. For more information check out the Janurary 2001 issue of Scientific American. -RUDY!
Map of the CMB fluctuations from http://arcturus.mit.edu/gallery/cobe.html

Inflation Sept. 12, 2001
COSMOLOGY: A SHORT COURSE
Steven Weinberg (UT)

The Physics Department's weekly colloquium featured Dr. Steven Weinberg presenting a "short course" on cosmology. The course provided an excellent introduction highlighting the history and recent advances in cosmology. Soon after this, the course reached a higher level as the speaker began developing the formulism that current literature is filled with. (The cryptic "Cl" and "l" notation was revealed to me for the first time.) The one comment from this short course that will stick with me concerns the current state of some astrophysicists. Dr. Weinberg pointed out that some rely so much on the computer models and simulations and not on the mathematical developement of the theory that they often report equations in articles that cannot be derived. Interesting... -RUDY!

From the Editor...

Usually toward the end or last half of a talk, a speaker will get technical and more difficult, this is due to two things, 1) the speaker has spent many years working in a field, and 2) the audience is composed of people with varying degrees of familiarity and expertise in the speakers field. The important thing to remember is that being utterly confused shouldn't hinder your attendance, nor damage your self esteem. Sage Advice: when the level of a talk gets to the level you have trouble following, it's best to put the pen down and listen more attentively. Often times a sentence or phrase among a flurry of upper level physics and mathematics jargon and equations will make the concept clear, however, it is easy to miss when you are busy trying to write down the last three things you are trying to grasp! -RUDY!

AAO image of M5
Sept. 12, 2001
A Texas View of Globular Clusters and Australia or Chemical Abundance Variation in Globular Clusters: Resent Results From Mildly Metal-Poor M 5
Inese Ivans (UT)

Ms. Ivans presented here a small portion of the research she conducted while visiting Australia. She obtained spectra of a number of stars from globular cluster M 5, from which she calculated the average, or "cluster" abundances of a number of atomic elements. Globular clusters are very large groups of stars that lie predominantly in the Galactic halo, and they are also very old, so they consist of very bright giant stars that are easy to observe. Because globulars are very old, some being perhaps as old as the Milky Way itself, studying their chemical composition yields information about the chemical composition of the early Galaxy. Here Ivans presented her abundance results for M 5, and she compared them to results from two different studies of M 4, another globular that is often called M 5's "twin", both being roughly similar in composition. The plot revealed some puzzling systematic differences among the three separate studies. Ms. Ivans's working theory is that these differences, rather than being inherent to the clusters, are caused by differences among the studies. For instance, one study modeled stellar atmospheres assuming that the stars being studied exhibited Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE), while her study used model atmospheres with Non-LTE effects, and the two differed significantly. She reported that upon repeating the other study using Non-LTE model atmospheres, the results of the two agreed much better. In conclusion, she cautioned that the results of this study of M 4 and M 5 indicate that other studies of globular clusters like these that assume LTE in stellar atmospheres may be incorrect and misleading. Non-LTE seems to be the way to go in this particular field of research! -HRJ

INTERLUDE: Metallicity

It is well known that practically all the elements in the periodic table (save for hydrogen, some helium and some lithium) are born in the core of a star. When these stars die, these elements are released into the interstellar medium, from which new stars are born. Therefore, stars are composed of a number of different elements. Astronomers use the term "metallicity", or "chemical abundance" to describe the amount of a particular element found a star. A preliminary word of warning, "metallicity" can have multiple meanings -- some scientists use the term in reference to the iron (Fe) content of the star alone, whereas others may use it to refer to the average of the abundances of a number of elements, since, remember, any element heavier than helium may be called a metal!

When studying an unknown or poorly-understood object, it is preferable to have another object to compare it to. This is astronomy's version of running a controlled experiment, so to speak. Before we can begin to grasp the behavior or properties of what we are studying, we must be able to compare it to something whose behaviors or properties we already understand. Therefore, when astronomers measure the chemical abundances of a star, they compare them to the chemical abundances of a star they know quite well. Most often than not, that star is our Sun, since we know no other star better.

Because metallicity calculations made relative to the Sun are so common, a notation has been developed to summarize the results. This bracket notation, [A/B], represents the ratio of the logarithms (base 10) of the chemical abundance, A/B, of a star to that of the sun:

[A/B] = log10(A/B)star - log10 (A/B)sun.

Astronomers discuss almost every number as a log, simply because the numbers they deal with (ages, distances, masses, etc.) are so very large.

You may ask why there is an A and a B here, when this is the measurement of the abundance of one particular element? Well, this is a subtlety of the notation. A star's chemical abundance is actually made relative to its abundance of hydrogen or its abundance of iron. As an example, a star's oxygen (O) abundance is often measured relative to its iron (Fe) abundance, and this is the ratio that is compared to that of O to Fe in the Sun within the bracket notation:

[O/Fe] = log10(O/Fe)star - log10 (O/Fe)sun.

Say for example that the above [O/Fe] = -2.0. The means that the star's oxygen O abundance (again relative to its iron Fe abundance) is 100 x less than (10-2) the oxygen abundance of the Sun (relative to the Sun's iron content). You may wonder why Fe is included at all here, since it only seems to confuse the issue. Well, it's there because most people find the ratios of elements in a star more interesting than the actual abundances themselves. This is because different mechanisms cause the release of different elements into the interstellar medium -- by knowing the ratio of different elements in a star, one gets an idea of what types of processes enriched the gas that the star formed from. So because iron is released into space by a particular process (a Type Ia supernova), and also because it is so easy to measure in stars, most element abundances are measured relative to it.

In the plot shown here, taken from one of Ivans's papers on M 5, [Na/Fe] is plotted versus [O/Fe]. Look at the star marked L4201 in the upper right. You can guess by eye that it has a [Na/Fe] ~ +0.31 and an [O/Fe] ~ +0.4. If you can remember your logs, 10+0.31 ~ 2 (indicating that L4201 has a ratio of sodium to iron twice that of the Sun) and 10+0.4 ~ 2.5 (meaning that its oxygen to iron ratio is 2.5x that of the Sun.)

Plots such as this that show the abundances of several stars together are common in papers and are useful for revealing trends and distributions of chemical abundances in groups of stars. More often than not, the motivation for a metallicity study of a star or cluster of stars is precisely this -- to gain a better understanding of the distributions of abundances of elements in, or the evolution of the chemical enrichment of, a large sample of stars.

-HRJ

KPNO image of the Virgo Cluster
Sept. 13, 2001
Direct Detection of Intergalactic Stars in the Virgo Cluster
Ted von Hippel (Wisconsin/WYNN)

Dr. von Hippel presented the latest results on the search for intergalactic stars in the Virgo cluster. Astronomers have thought that intergalactic stars must exist, only now with the HST have they been observed. These stars are believed to be left behind during the often violent interaction of galaxies. Searching in clusters is the logical place to look since galaxy interactions would occur frequently. Intergalactic stars are useful tools for astronomers to determine distances independent of individual galaxies in the cluster. The traits of the intergalactic stars can provide hints and constraints for cluster formation theories. The intergalactic stars observed by HST have a distance consistent with those determined with the galaxies in the cluster. -RUDY!

INTERESTED IN CONTRIBUTING?

It's easy! Find an event you would like to attend and review, then contact me and I will give you some pointers and instructions on writing your review. It's a win/win situation!

STAY ON TOP WITH THESE EVENT CALENDARS:




Astronomy Students' Association